Failure to Timely Report Resident-to-Resident Abuse
Summary
The facility failed to report an alleged incident of resident-to-resident physical abuse to the New York State Department of Health within the required 2-hour timeframe. The incident involved two residents, one of whom hit the other on the shoulder with a grabber. The incident occurred at approximately 1:40 PM, and the facility's Administrator was made aware of it by 1:55 PM. However, the report was not submitted to the Department of Health until the following day at 12:31 PM. Resident #193, who was hit, was admitted with diagnoses including end-stage renal disease, cerebral infarction, and polyneuropathy, and was cognitively impaired. Resident #325, who committed the act, was admitted with diagnoses including Alzheimer's disease, unspecified dementia, and major depressive disorder, and was severely impaired in cognition. The incident was witnessed by a Certified Nursing Assistant who reported it to a Registered Nurse, who then informed the Assistant Director of Nursing and the Director of Nursing. Despite the facility's policy requiring immediate reporting of abuse allegations, the Assistant Director of Nursing did not receive instructions from the Director of Nursing to report the incident until the next day. Both the Director of Nursing and the Administrator acknowledged the requirement to report such incidents within 2 hours but could not recall why the report was delayed. This failure to report in a timely manner constitutes a deficiency in the facility's compliance with state regulations.
Plan Of Correction
Plan of Correction: Approved December 30, 2024 1. What corrective action(s) will be accomplished for those residents found to have been affected by the deficient practice? Resident #193 and resident #325 were identified as being directly affected by the alleged gap in practice. The facility did not ensure that an alleged violation involving resident-to-resident physical abuse was reported immediately, but no later than 2 hours after allegations were made to the State Survey Agency. - An investigation was conducted and concluded that the altercation was sudden in nature and was not premeditated. - Resident #193 and #325 were separated. Resident #325 was transferred to another unit. - Resident #193 and #325 were assessed and monitored. - Resident #193 and #325 medical provider and family were notified of the incident. - Resident #193 and #325 were seen and evaluated by the psychologist. - Resident #325 was seen and evaluated by the psychiatrist. - Social Services provided emotional support to residents #193 and #325. - The incident was reported to the NYS-DOH on 7/29/24. - RN #4 was re-educated on actual/alleged abuse reporting to ensure that the NYS-DOH is notified within 2 hours after the incident/allegation. - CNA #7 was re-educated on abuse prevention and reporting. 2. How will you identify other residents having the potential to be affected by the same deficient practice and what corrective action will be taken? The facility respectfully states that all residents have the potential to be affected by the alleged gap in practice. All incidents and accidents for the preceding 30 days were reviewed by the Assistant Directors of Nursing to ensure that any incidents of alleged or actual abuse or incidents involving serious injury were reported timely to the DON and Administrator, as required, to the state agency and all other required agencies (i.e. law enforcement when applicable). In the event that non-compliance was identified, the incident will be immediately reported to all required entities and staff involved re-inserviced on the required timeframes to report. Responsible Party: Assistant Directors of Nursing 3. What measures will be put in place or what systemic changes will you make to ensure that the deficient practice does not occur? 1. The Policy and Procedure for Abuse- Prohibition Protocol, Types of Abuse, Response/Reporting Prevention/Response/Reporting was reviewed to assure compliance with F609 by the Administrator in conjunction with the Director of Nursing, Director of QA/PI, and Medical Director and revised accordingly. The change in policy includes: - Any alleged violations involving mistreatment, neglect, or abuse, including serious injuries of an unknown source must be reported to the Administrator/Designee, or department director immediately. An immediate investigation must be made and the findings of such investigation must be reported to the NYSDOH via Electronic Incident Reporting form within 2 hours of occurrence/discovery. Responsible Party: Administrator, DON, Medical Director, QA/PI 2. The Policy and Procedure for Abuse Reporting was reviewed to assure compliance with F609 by the Administrator in conjunction with the Director of Nursing, Director of QA/PI, and Medical Director and found to be in compliance. Responsible Party: Administrator, DON, Medical Director, Director of QA/PI 3. Inservice education will be provided by the Inservice Coordinator/designee to all staff on abuse, neglect, and mistreatment including injuries of unknown origin regarding reporting requirements related to violations involving abuse to the NYSDOH and NYPD, immediately. Education on Abuse Prohibition Protocol will continue to be provided to staff upon hire and annually thereafter. Highlights of the lesson plan include: - The facility staff must immediately report all alleged violations of mistreatment, neglect, and abuse, including injuries of unknown origin and misappropriation of resident property to the RNM/RNS/ADON. An investigation is to immediately follow. - The RNM/RNS/ADON will immediately notify the DON who will notify the Administrator. - Upon notification, the Assistant Director of Nursing/Designee must report alleged violations of mistreatment, neglect, and abuse, including injuries of unknown origin and misappropriation of resident property immediately to the NYSDOH and as appropriate to other required agencies (i.e., NYPD). Responsible Party: Inservice Coordinator/Designee 4. The Residents Occurrence Log-In form (SAFETY-967) was reviewed and revised to ensure that actual/allegation of abuse is reported to the NY-DOH within 2 hours of the incident/allegation. Revision of form included adding: - Reportable (Y/N) - Date/Time Reported to DOH - Date/Time Reported to Other Agency Responsible Party: QA/PI 4. How will the corrective action(s) be monitored to ensure the deficient practice will not recur? 1. An audit tool will be developed to monitor the facility’s compliance with ensuring that all accidents and incidents are investigated, and abuse is reported timely as per NYSDOH and Federal reporting guidelines. Responsible Party: QA/PI 2. All accidents/incidents and grievances involving alleged abuse or serious injuries will be audited daily by the Assistant Director of Nursing/designee for 30 days and then monthly for 3 months, using the new audit tool to ensure compliance. Any identified issues will be immediately addressed and shared at the Morning Meeting. Responsible Party: Assistant Director of Nursing/Designee 3. The results of the accidents and incidents audits will be analyzed for trends and patterns. Responsible Party: QA/PI Coordinator 4. Results of the accidents and incidents audit will be presented and discussed at the facility quarterly QA/PI meetings. Responsible Party: QA/PI Coordinator 5. Date for correction and the title of the person responsible for correction of deficiency. Deficiency will be corrected by (MONTH) 7, 2025, 60 days from the survey exit date. Person responsible for correction is the Administrator.
Penalty
Resources
Below are regulatory guidelines relevant to this citation:
A resident exited the building through a bedroom window, walked off the property, and was observed and redirected by staff with assistance from law enforcement, who encountered the resident down the road and helped escort the resident back. The facility’s internal documentation lacked staff or witness statements and characterized the event as the resident remaining on facility grounds without injury. Despite the resident’s account, a police report, and a maintenance staff report confirming that the resident left the premises and that law enforcement responded, the DON did not report the incident to required state and federal agencies, even though the DON acknowledged that any incident involving law enforcement response must be reported.
Failure to timely report alleged verbal abuse: A volunteer reported that an activities staff member yelled at a resident during bingo, told the resident to stop interrupting, and also yelled at the volunteer when she intervened. The resident later described the staff member as rude and said the comment made him/her angry. Survey review found no evidence the allegation was reported, and the RCD confirmed the facility had no evidence of reporting despite policy requiring immediate reporting of abuse allegations.
The facility failed to ensure that alleged abuse and serious injuries were reported to the State Survey Agency as required, instead either reporting only to a state patient safety system or not reporting at all. One resident with severe cognitive impairment sustained bilateral femur fractures after a fall, another cognitively impaired resident with Parkinson’s disease was later found to have a femur fracture after being discovered on the floor, and a third cognitively impaired resident required ORIF surgery for fractures following a fall; none of these incidents were reported through the State Survey Agency’s incident reporting website, per the ADM. In addition, an allegation that a resident with dementia and sensory impairments may have been molested was documented in the abuse binder but not in the medical record, and the ADM did not report the allegation to agencies or law enforcement after deeming it not credible, despite interviewing the resident and family. These actions and omissions resulted in multiple unreported events that met criteria for immediate reporting of alleged abuse and injuries of unknown source.
The facility failed to timely complete and document the results of an abuse investigation after a resident with TBI, anxiety, and mild neurocognitive disorder became increasingly agitated, allegedly attacked staff, and was subsequently taken to the floor by a nurse, resulting in severe left hip pain with leg shortening and external rotation and transfer to the ED. Although an event report was submitted to the State Agency, the investigation report produced later lacked the required PB-22 and did not include the outcome of the investigation, and the DON confirmed the investigation remained incomplete beyond the required timeframe.
A resident with altered mental status developed bilateral wrist discoloration and swelling during ADL care when a CNA reported the resident was resisting and bumped both wrists against a wheelchair during transfer. An RN completed an incident report and nursing note documenting the injury, assessment, and physician notification with an order for x-ray. Facility leadership later acknowledged that this event, which met their policy criteria for an allegation requiring reporting within two hours if involving abuse or serious bodily injury, was not reported to the state survey agency, contrary to the facility’s written abuse, neglect, and exploitation policy.
The facility failed to report an allegation of physical abuse to law enforcement as required by its abuse reporting policy. A cognitively intact resident with dementia, anxiety, bipolar disorder, and major depressive disorder reported refusing a shower when a NA placed a lift sling under them, after which the situation escalated and both the resident and the NA exchanged punches. Skin assessments documented multiple new bruises on both of the resident’s arms and hands that were not present the prior day. Although facility policy required timely notification of law enforcement for such allegations, documentation in the abuse report form and EHR showed no law enforcement notification, and facility leadership confirmed that the incident and bruising were not reported to police.
Failure to Report Elopement Incident Involving Law Enforcement
Penalty
Summary
The deficiency involves the facility’s failure to report an elopement incident to required state and federal agencies as mandated by 42 CFR 483.12(c). On the referenced date, Resident #5 exited the building through his bedroom window around 12:15 PM and walked across the facility property toward the perimeter fence. A CNA observed the resident outside and called for assistance, after which staff redirected and escorted the resident back into the building and placed him on one-to-one supervision. The facility’s internal incident documentation noted the window exit and subsequent maintenance inspection of the window seals but did not include any staff or witness statements. The DON later stated that the resident never left facility grounds and was returned without injury, and therefore the incident was not considered reportable. However, interviews and external records showed that the resident did leave the facility premises and that law enforcement was involved. Resident #5 recalled being outside the facility, being brought back by staff and a “police man,” and being told by the officer not to leave again. A police report from the local police department confirmed an encounter with the resident outside the facility and that an officer assisted staff in escorting him back. Maintenance staff (Staff G) also reported that the resident climbed out the window, left the facility property, and was stopped “down the road,” then redirected back with law enforcement assistance. In interviews, the DON initially denied that law enforcement had been notified or involved, then later acknowledged that law enforcement had responded but asserted they did not come into the facility. The DON also confirmed awareness that any incident in which law enforcement investigates or responds is required to be reported, yet the elopement and law enforcement involvement were not reported to the State Survey Agency or other required officials within the required time frames.
Failure to Timely Report Alleged Verbal Abuse
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to ensure an allegation of verbal abuse was reported timely for resident #55. A volunteer submitted a grievance stating that during bingo on 2/14/26, activities staff member #1 yelled at resident #55 after the resident called out bingo and told the resident to stop interrupting while she was talking. The volunteer reported that the staff member continued yelling for a couple of minutes, and when the volunteer intervened and told the staff member to stop yelling at the resident, the staff member yelled at the volunteer as well. The grievance also stated that two residents, including resident #55 and resident #66, reported that the activities staff member yells at them all the time and speaks to them the same way every time they play bingo. Resident #55 later stated that the issue involved the activities staff member being rude during bingo and saying, in a smart-ass way, "weren't you paying attention?" The resident said the comment made him/her angry and that [he/she] called the staff member names. The volunteer confirmed hearing the staff member speak loudly and rudely to the resident and then yell at the volunteer before storming off. Review of the state survey agency incident database showed no evidence the allegation was reported, and the regional clinical director confirmed the facility had no evidence the verbal abuse allegation was reported. The facility policy required alleged abuse to be reported to the Administrator, state agency, adult protective services, and other required agencies within specified timeframes, immediately but no later than 2 hours when the allegation involved abuse or serious bodily injury.
Failure to Report Alleged Abuse and Serious Injuries to State Survey Agency
Penalty
Summary
The deficiency involves the facility’s failure to ensure that all alleged violations of abuse, including injuries of unknown source and incidents involving major injuries, were reported immediately to the State Survey Agency and other officials as required by state law. For four sampled residents, the Administrator acknowledged that incidents were reported only to the state’s patient safety website and not to the State Survey Agency’s incident reporting website. This omission meant that the State Survey Agency did not receive timely notice of serious events, including an allegation of sexual abuse and multiple incidents resulting in significant fractures and surgery. For one resident with severely impaired cognition and diagnoses including hemiplegia and hemiparesis, nursing notes documented that the resident was found on the floor after attempting to get out of bed, was sent to the ER, and returned with immobilizing braces on both legs due to bilateral femur fractures. The resident’s bones were not strong enough for surgery, and he was placed on comfort care. Despite the seriousness of the injuries and the requirement to treat such events as potential abuse or neglect until ruled out, the Administrator stated that this incident was reported only to the state’s patient safety website and not to the State Survey Agency’s incident reporting system. Another resident with Parkinson’s disease and severely impaired cognition was found on the floor after a wheelchair alarm sounded, initially with no visible injury and able to bear weight. A few days later, staff documented complaints of left leg pain, tenderness, and wincing with movement, leading to an order for x‑rays and transfer for imaging. X‑ray results revealed a femur fracture, and surgery was not pursued. The Administrator reported this incident to the state’s patient safety website but not to the State Survey Agency’s incident reporting website. A third resident with severe cognitive impairment experienced a fall with complaints of pain in the left knee, left elbow, and fingers, and later underwent ORIF surgery for fractures of the right fourth and fifth metacarpals; this incident also was not reported to the State Survey Agency’s incident reporting system, according to the Administrator. For another resident with dementia, adjustment disorder with anxiety, hearing and visual loss, and age‑related debility, a document in the facility’s abuse binder described a possible molestation allegation originating from a phone call by the resident’s nephew. The nephew reported that his mother, the resident’s sister and then‑POA, was emotionally unstable and had stated she felt the resident had reported being molested. The Administrator documented that the nephew did not believe the allegation was credible, that the sister had dementia and emotional issues, and that the Administrator considered the report “not a viable allegation.” The Administrator noted that he interviewed the resident, who denied being touched, and that the sister could not provide more details beyond stating that a man had groped the resident’s breast. The Administrator concluded the allegation was not credible and did not report it to any agencies or law enforcement. The incident was not documented in the resident’s medical record, and the Administrator confirmed in interview that he did not report this sexual abuse allegation to the State Survey Agency’s incident reporting website. Across these four residents, the common deficiency was the facility’s failure to treat serious injuries and a sexual abuse allegation as reportable events to the State Survey Agency, as required. Instead, the Administrator limited reporting to the state’s patient safety website or chose not to report at all when he personally judged an allegation as not credible. This pattern of inaction regarding mandated reporting requirements formed the basis of the cited deficiency.
Failure to Timely Complete Abuse Investigation After Staff–Resident Altercation With Serious Injury
Penalty
Summary
The deficiency involves the facility’s failure to timely complete and report an investigative report for an allegation of physical abuse resulting in serious bodily injury. Facility policy on Reporting Unusual Occurrences requires that suspected, alleged, or actual abuse, neglect, misappropriation of resident property, fractures, incidents requiring transfer for medical evaluation, and staff-to-resident altercations be reported to appropriate agencies, with a written report forwarded within five working days. Federal regulation at 42 CFR §483.12(c)(4) similarly requires that, at the conclusion of the investigation and no later than five working days of the incident, the facility must report the results of the investigation. The facility’s Abuse policy states that each resident has the right to be free from abuse, including infliction of injury with resulting physical harm, pain, or mental anguish. Clinical record review showed that the resident had diagnoses including traumatic brain injury, anxiety, and mild neurocognitive disorder with behavioral disturbance. A nursing progress note documented that supervisors were urgently called to a unit for a resident attacking staff; upon arrival, the resident was found lying on his right side, screaming, and complaining of left hip pain. The resident stated that a staff member had “tackled” him and that he had intended to “knock his ass out.” Witness accounts indicated the resident had increasing agitation and attempted to punch the nurse and nurse aides; the nurse reported that when the resident swung at him, he grabbed the resident’s arm/shoulder and took him down to the floor. The resident had 10/10 left hip pain with left leg shortening and external rotation, and the physician ordered transfer to a local emergency room. An event report was submitted to the State Agency the following morning, but the facility’s investigation report produced a week later did not include a PB-22 or the outcome of the investigation. In an interview, the DON confirmed the investigation was not complete and acknowledged the facility failed to timely complete the investigative report for this allegation of physical abuse with serious bodily injury.
Failure to Timely Report Allegation of Potential Abuse-Related Injury
Penalty
Summary
The facility failed to timely report an allegation of potential abuse related to an injury sustained by Resident 94 during ADL care. Resident 94, who had a diagnosis including altered mental status, was admitted on an unspecified date and later developed discoloration and swelling of both wrists during clothing changes and transfer by a CNA. An incident report dated 03/20/25 at 9:45 PM, written by an RN, documented that the CNA reported the resident developed bilateral wrist discoloration during ADL care while the resident was resisting, and that the resident bumped both wrists against the wheelchair during transfer. The RN’s documentation noted assessment of the resident’s wrists, presence of discoloration and swelling, and that the physician was notified and ordered an x-ray to rule out fracture, with ice applied to the affected areas. Interviews with facility leadership confirmed that this incident was not reported to the state survey agency (SSA). The CEO stated that the incident from 03/20/25 was not reported to the SSA. The Administrator, who was the DON at the time of the incident, stated that the facility’s practice was to report all allegations of abuse or injury of unknown origin within two hours, but acknowledged that this allegation was not reported because they determined it was not an injury of unknown origin or abuse. Review of the facility’s Abuse, Neglect and Exploitation policy, revised 11/2021, showed a requirement to report all alleged violations to the Administrator, state agency, adult protective services, and other required agencies within specified timeframes, including immediately but not later than two hours after the allegation is made if the events involve abuse or result in serious bodily injury.
Failure to Report Alleged Physical Abuse and Resulting Bruising to Law Enforcement
Penalty
Summary
The deficiency involves the facility’s failure to report an allegation of physical abuse to law enforcement within the required timeframe. Facility policy, revised 08/08/2024, required the administrator or designee to notify multiple entities, including law enforcement, no later than two hours after an allegation involving serious bodily injury or within 24 hours if there was no serious bodily injury. The policy also specified notification of the state licensing authority, Ombudsman, resident representative, APS, the resident’s attending physician, and the facility medical director. Despite this written requirement, documentation showed that law enforcement was not notified following an allegation of physical abuse involving a resident. The resident involved had been admitted in 2019 and had diagnoses including moderate vascular dementia with agitation, generalized anxiety disorder, bipolar disorder, and major depressive disorder. A recent MDS showed a BIMS score of 15, indicating the resident was cognitively intact, and noted episodes of care rejection but no documented physical behavioral symptoms toward others. On the date of the incident, a NA entered the resident’s room, placed a lift sling under the resident, and informed the resident they would be taking a shower; the resident reported refusing the bath and stated that the situation escalated into both the resident and the NA exchanging punches. Subsequent skin assessments documented multiple bruises on both upper extremities that were not present the day before. A Potential Resident Abuse Report Form and the EHR contained no evidence that law enforcement was notified, and both the Administrator and Social Services Supervisor confirmed in interviews that the allegation of physical abuse and associated bruising were not reported to law enforcement, contrary to facility policy and reporting requirements.
Trusted data from CMS and state health departments
Every citation, penalty and Plan of Correction is sourced from public CMS records (latest release June 24, 2026) and official state health department websites — never guesswork.
Trusted by long-term care providers and associations.
